Skip to content
AGENCY INDEX
vs

Agency comparison · Minnesota

Olive & Company vs Windmill Strategy: Minnesota marketing agency comparison

Olive & Company is a Minneapolis, Minnesota agency that lists branding, content, PPC / paid search and 2 more. Windmill Strategy is a Minneapolis, Minnesota agency that lists branding, content, AI search (GEO) and 4 more. Windmill Strategy lists a lower minimum project ($3,000) than Olive & Company ($5,000). Only Windmill Strategy lists AI search (GEO) and Social.

Last updated

Olive & Company and Windmill Strategy: the agencies

  • Olive & Company (founded 2003): Minneapolis agency pairing branding, web design and digital marketing to help growth-focused firms sharpen their brand and generate leads.

    Full profile

  • Windmill Strategy (founded 2006): Minneapolis agency focused on industrial and technical B2B companies, combining web design, digital marketing and branding.

    Full profile

Olive & Company vs Windmill Strategy: side by side

Each value for Olive & Company and Windmill Strategy comes from the agency's listing, its company facts or the platform named under it. Data as of October 15, 2026. No score or rank here; see the full ranking on the agencies page.
Olive & Company vs Windmill Strategy, side by side
FieldOlive & CompanyWindmill Strategy
City and regionMinneapolis · Twin CitiesMinneapolis · Twin Cities
Headquarters219 Main Street SE #503, Minneapolis, 55414Source: oliveandcompany.com1400 Van Buren Street #200-12, Minneapolis, 55413Source: windmillstrategy.com
Employees11-50Source: clutch.co11-50Source: clutch.co
Founded2003Source: oliveandcompany.com2006Source: windmillstrategy.com
ServicesBranding, Content, PPC / paid search, SEO, Web designListing sources: clutch.co, oliveandcompany.comBranding, Content, AI search (GEO), PPC / paid search, SEO, Social, Web designListing sources: clutch.co, windmillstrategy.com
IndustriesHealthcareListing sources: clutch.co, oliveandcompany.comManufacturing, B2B tech, HealthcareListing sources: clutch.co, windmillstrategy.com
Google rating4.6 ★ (11 reviews)via Google · fetched October 12, 2026View on Google4.9 ★ (69 reviews)via Google · fetched October 12, 2026View on Google
Clutch rating5.0 ★ (2 reviews)via Clutch4.9 ★ (24 reviews)via Clutch
Minimum project$5,000+Listing sources: clutch.co, oliveandcompany.com$3,000+Listing sources: clutch.co, windmillstrategy.com
Hourly band$150-199/hrListing sources: clutch.co, oliveandcompany.com$150-199/hrListing sources: clutch.co, windmillstrategy.com
Publishes pricingNoListing sources: clutch.co, oliveandcompany.comYes, on its own siteListing sources: clutch.co, windmillstrategy.com
OwnershipNot publishedOwner-operated, no parent company listedSource: windmillstrategy.com
Partner programsNot published4 programs
Notable clients12+ named clients on record12+ named clients on record
Leadership
CertificationsNot publishedGoogle Partner
Case studies4 (1 with stated results)Source: oliveandcompany.com4 (3 with stated results)Source: windmillstrategy.com
AI-assistant mention rateNamed in 34 of 399 answered runs (8.5%); 95% interval 6.2%–11.7%How AI visibility is measuredNamed in 79 of 399 answered runs (19.8%); 95% interval 16.2%–24.0%How AI visibility is measured

Not published by either agency: Yelp rating, awards.

Olive & Company listing sources

  1. [1] clutch.co
  2. [2] oliveandcompany.com

Windmill Strategy listing sources

  1. [1] clutch.co
  2. [2] windmillstrategy.com
See how every listed agency is ranked

Olive & Company vs Windmill Strategy: where they differ

  • Founded: Olive & Company 2003 and Windmill Strategy 2006.
  • Only Windmill Strategy lists AI search (GEO) and Social among its services.
  • Only Windmill Strategy lists Manufacturing and B2B tech among its industries.
  • Google: Olive & Company 4.6 from 11 reviews and Windmill Strategy 4.9 from 69 reviews.
  • Clutch: Olive & Company 5.0 from 2 reviews and Windmill Strategy 4.9 from 24 reviews.
  • Minimum project: Olive & Company $5,000+ and Windmill Strategy $3,000+.
  • Windmill Strategy publishes pricing on its own site; Olive & Company does not.
  • AI mentions: Olive & Company 8.5% and Windmill Strategy 19.8% (95% intervals do not overlap).

Olive & Company vs Windmill Strategy: where they overlap

What Olive & Company and Windmill Strategy have in common as Minnesota agencies, from their listings and company facts:

  • Olive & Company and Windmill Strategy both list branding, content, PPC / paid search, SEO and web design.
  • Olive & Company and Windmill Strategy both list healthcare among their industries.
  • Olive & Company and Windmill Strategy are both based in Minneapolis, Minnesota.
  • In MN Agency Index's October 12, 2026 test of 38 Minnesota buyer questions across 5 AI assistants (399 answers), Olive & Company and Windmill Strategy were named in the same answer 12 times (3.0% of answers).

Olive & Company vs Windmill Strategy: AI visibility by assistant

In MN Agency Index's October 12, 2026 test of 38 Minnesota buyer questions across 5 AI assistants (399 answers), Olive & Company was named in 34 answers (8.5%; 95% interval 6.2%–11.7%) and Windmill Strategy was named in 79 answers (19.8%; 95% interval 16.2%–24.0%); their 95% intervals do not overlap.Below: share of each assistant’s answers that named each agency. Single test run, October 12, 2026; repeated quarterly. Compare questions are excluded. Runs are correlated, so read each interval as a stability range. How AI visibility is measured.
  • ChatGPT
    Olive & Company

    ChatGPT named Olive & Company in 0 of 114 answers (0.0%).

    Windmill Strategy

    ChatGPT named Windmill Strategy in 14 of 114 answers (12.3%).

  • Gemini
    Olive & Company

    Gemini named Olive & Company in 12 of 114 answers (10.5%).

    Windmill Strategy

    Gemini named Windmill Strategy in 30 of 114 answers (26.3%).

  • Google AI Mode
    Olive & Company

    Google AI Mode named Olive & Company in 12 of 114 answers (10.5%).

    Windmill Strategy

    Google AI Mode named Windmill Strategy in 20 of 114 answers (17.5%).

  • Google AI Overview
    Olive & Company

    Google AI Overview named Olive & Company in 2 of 19 answers (10.5%).

    Windmill Strategy

    Google AI Overview named Windmill Strategy in 4 of 19 answers (21.1%).

  • Microsoft Copilot
    Olive & Company

    Microsoft Copilot named Olive & Company in 8 of 38 answers (21.1%).

    Windmill Strategy

    Microsoft Copilot named Windmill Strategy in 11 of 38 answers (28.9%).

Bar = share of that assistant’s answers naming the agency; whisker = 95% interval.

Olive & Company vs Windmill Strategy: common questions

How do Olive & Company and Windmill Strategy compare for branding in Minnesota?

Olive & Company and Windmill Strategy both list branding. Both are based in Minneapolis. Olive & Company was founded in 2003 and Windmill Strategy was founded in 2006. Listed team sizes: Olive & Company 11-50 and Windmill Strategy 11-50 employees.

Which agency has been operating longer, Olive & Company or Windmill Strategy?

Olive & Company, founded in 2003. Windmill Strategy was founded in 2006.

How many Google reviews do Olive & Company and Windmill Strategy have?

Olive & Company has 11 reviews (4.6 average) and Windmill Strategy has 69 reviews (4.9 average). Review count isn't a quality measure.

Do Olive & Company and Windmill Strategy publish pricing on their own sites?

Windmill Strategy publishes pricing on its own site; Olive & Company does not.

Who runs Olive & Company and Windmill Strategy?

Olive & Company: Rob Haskin (Co-Founder; Partner, Chief Executive Officer) and Tom Keekley (Co-Founder; Partner, Chief Customer Officer); Windmill Strategy: Kathy Kassera Mrozek (President & CEO). As listed on each company's own pages.

Which clients do Olive & Company and Windmill Strategy name publicly?

Olive & Company names NexTech Academy, Korbyt and Summit Mortgage (case studies); Windmill Strategy names Stillwell Inc. (case study), SMC Ltd. (case study) and Spraymation Inc. (testimonial).

How many employees do Olive & Company and Windmill Strategy list?

Both list 11-50 employees.

Which industries do Olive & Company and Windmill Strategy both list?

Healthcare.

How comparisons are chosen and every field is sourced: methodology.

Olive & Company vs Windmill Strategy: related Minnesota pages

Not a recommendation. Fit depends on your budget, service and industry.

Request a correction