Skip to content
AGENCY INDEX
Carmichael Lynch logovsColle McVoy logo

Agency comparison · Minnesota

Carmichael Lynch vs Colle McVoy: Minnesota marketing agency comparison

Carmichael Lynch is a Minneapolis, Minnesota agency that lists branding and advertising. Colle McVoy is a Minneapolis, Minnesota agency that lists branding and advertising. Company-stated awards on record: Carmichael Lynch 9 and Colle McVoy 5.

Last updated

Carmichael Lynch and Colle McVoy: the agencies

  • Carmichael Lynch (founded 1962): Minneapolis and Philadelphia creative advertising agency known for brand campaigns, with a media planning arm, for clients like Subaru, Bush's and Korbel.

    Full profile

  • Colle McVoy: Minneapolis creative advertising agency doing brand campaigns, media planning and buying, and retail experience work for consumer brands.

    Full profile

Carmichael Lynch vs Colle McVoy: side by side

Each value for Carmichael Lynch and Colle McVoy comes from the agency's listing, its company facts or the platform named under it. Data as of October 16, 2026. No score or rank here; see the full ranking on the agencies page.
Carmichael Lynch vs Colle McVoy, side by side
FieldCarmichael LynchColle McVoy
City and regionMinneapolis · Twin CitiesMinneapolis · Twin Cities
Headquarters110 N. 5th St. 10th Floor, Minneapolis, MN, 55403Source: carmichaellynch.com250 North 3rd Avenue, Suite 400, Minneapolis, 55401Source: collemcvoy.com
Employees201-500Source: builtincolorado.comNot published
Founded1962Source: carmichaellynch.comNot published
ServicesBranding, AdvertisingListing sources: carmichaellynch.com, glassdoor.com, carmichaellynch.comBranding, AdvertisingListing sources: collemcvoy.com
IndustriesNot publishedRetail & e-commerceListing sources: collemcvoy.com
Google rating4.8 ★ (12 reviews)via Google · fetched October 12, 2026View on Google4.8 ★ (8 reviews)via Google · fetched October 12, 2026View on Google
Publishes pricingNoListing sources: carmichaellynch.com, glassdoor.com, carmichaellynch.comNoListing sources: collemcvoy.com
Awards9 awardsCompany-stated5 awardsCompany-stated
Notable clients12+ named clients on record4 named clients on record
Leadership
Case studies4 (0 with stated results)Source: carmichaellynch.com4 (0 with stated results)Source: collemcvoy.com
AI-assistant mention rateNamed in 3 of 431 answered runs (0.7%); 95% interval 0.2%–2.0%How AI visibility is measuredNamed in 11 of 431 answered runs (2.5%); 95% interval 1.4%–4.5%How AI visibility is measured

Not published by either agency: Clutch rating, Yelp rating, minimum project, hourly band, ownership, partner programs, certifications.

Carmichael Lynch listing sources

  1. [1] carmichaellynch.com
  2. [2] glassdoor.com
  3. [3] carmichaellynch.com

Colle McVoy listing sources

  1. [1] collemcvoy.com
See how every listed agency is ranked

Carmichael Lynch vs Colle McVoy: where they differ

  • Google: Carmichael Lynch 4.8 from 12 reviews and Colle McVoy 4.8 from 8 reviews.
  • Company-stated awards on record: Carmichael Lynch 9 and Colle McVoy 5.
  • AI mentions: Carmichael Lynch 0.7% and Colle McVoy 2.5% (within the margin of error).

Carmichael Lynch vs Colle McVoy: where they overlap

What Carmichael Lynch and Colle McVoy have in common as Minnesota agencies, from their listings and company facts:

  • Carmichael Lynch and Colle McVoy both list advertising and branding.
  • Carmichael Lynch and Colle McVoy are both based in Minneapolis, Minnesota.
  • In MN Agency Index's tests of 38 Minnesota buyer questions across 7 AI assistants (Oct 12–16, 2026; 431 answers), Carmichael Lynch and Colle McVoy were named in the same answer 1 time (0.2% of answers).

Carmichael Lynch vs Colle McVoy: AI visibility by assistant

In MN Agency Index's tests of 38 Minnesota buyer questions across 7 AI assistants (Oct 12–16, 2026; 431 answers), Carmichael Lynch was named in 3 answers (0.7%; 95% interval 0.2%–2.0%) and Colle McVoy was named in 11 answers (2.5%; 95% interval 1.4%–4.5%); the difference is within the margin of error.Below: share of each assistant’s answers that named each agency. 2 test runs pooled, Oct 12–16, 2026; repeated quarterly. Compare questions are excluded. Runs are correlated, so read each interval as a stability range. How AI visibility is measured.
  • ChatGPT
    Carmichael Lynch

    ChatGPT named Carmichael Lynch in 0 of 119 answers (0.0%).

    Colle McVoy

    ChatGPT named Colle McVoy in 0 of 119 answers (0.0%).

  • Gemini
    Carmichael Lynch

    Gemini named Carmichael Lynch in 1 of 119 answers (0.8%).

    Colle McVoy

    Gemini named Colle McVoy in 3 of 119 answers (2.5%).

  • Google AI Mode
    Carmichael Lynch

    Google AI Mode named Carmichael Lynch in 1 of 119 answers (0.8%).

    Colle McVoy

    Google AI Mode named Colle McVoy in 7 of 119 answers (5.9%).

  • Google AI Overview
    Carmichael Lynch

    Google AI Overview named Carmichael Lynch in 0 of 21 answers (0.0%).

    Colle McVoy

    Google AI Overview named Colle McVoy in 0 of 21 answers (0.0%).

  • Microsoft Copilot
    Carmichael Lynch

    Microsoft Copilot named Carmichael Lynch in 1 of 43 answers (2.3%).

    Colle McVoy

    Microsoft Copilot named Colle McVoy in 1 of 43 answers (2.3%).

  • Perplexity (Sonar API)
    Carmichael LynchToo few answers for a rate

    Perplexity (Sonar API) named Carmichael Lynch in 0 of 5 answers.

    Colle McVoyToo few answers for a rate

    Perplexity (Sonar API) named Colle McVoy in 0 of 5 answers.

  • Gemini API (grounded)
    Carmichael LynchToo few answers for a rate

    Gemini API (grounded) named Carmichael Lynch in 0 of 5 answers.

    Colle McVoyToo few answers for a rate

    Gemini API (grounded) named Colle McVoy in 0 of 5 answers.

Bar = share of that assistant’s answers naming the agency; whisker = 95% interval.

Carmichael Lynch vs Colle McVoy: common questions

How do Carmichael Lynch and Colle McVoy compare for advertising in Minnesota?

Carmichael Lynch and Colle McVoy both list advertising. Both are based in Minneapolis. Google ratings: Carmichael Lynch 4.8 from 12 reviews and Colle McVoy 4.8 from 8 reviews. In MN Agency Index's AI test, Carmichael Lynch was named in 0.7% of 431 answers and Colle McVoy was named in 2.5% of 431 answers.

How many Google reviews do Carmichael Lynch and Colle McVoy have?

Carmichael Lynch has 12 reviews (4.8 average) and Colle McVoy has 8 reviews (4.8 average). Review count isn't a quality measure.

Do Carmichael Lynch and Colle McVoy publish pricing on their own sites?

No. None of Carmichael Lynch and Colle McVoy publishes pricing on its own site.

Who runs Carmichael Lynch and Colle McVoy?

Carmichael Lynch: Stacy Janicki (Chief Executive Officer), Tracey Santilli (President) and Alissa Anderson (Executive Vice President); Colle McVoy: Jessica Henrichs (Chief Executive Officer) and Steve Knapp (Managing Director, Media & Data Science). As listed on each company's own pages.

Which clients do Carmichael Lynch and Colle McVoy name publicly?

Carmichael Lynch names Xfinity, Independence Blue Cross and Butterball (case studies); Colle McVoy names La-Z-Boy, Frank's RedHot and 3M (case studies).

How many case studies are on record for Carmichael Lynch and Colle McVoy?

Carmichael Lynch 4 (0 with stated results) and Colle McVoy 4 (0 with stated results).

How often did AI assistants name Carmichael Lynch and Colle McVoy in MN Agency Index's test?

In MN Agency Index's tests of 38 Minnesota buyer questions across 7 AI assistants (Oct 12–16, 2026; 431 answers), Carmichael Lynch was named in 3 answers (0.7%; 95% interval 0.2%–2.0%) and Colle McVoy was named in 11 answers (2.5%; 95% interval 1.4%–4.5%); the difference is within the margin of error.

How comparisons are chosen and every field is sourced: methodology.

Carmichael Lynch vs Colle McVoy: also compared

Carmichael Lynch vs Colle McVoy: related Minnesota pages

Not a recommendation. Fit depends on your budget, service and industry.

Request a correction